Every DTC brand that hits $1M in annual revenue eventually confronts the same question. Do we keep building our Shopify store in-house, or do we bring in an agency that lives on the platform full-time? The right answer is almost always “bring in an agency”, but which agency depends on what stage of growth you’re in, what your store’s bottleneck actually is, and what your budget tolerance looks like. This roundup covers ten of the more widely-cited Shopify agencies currently working with DTC brands, grouped by specialty rather than ranked, because there is no objective #1.
Mid-market specialists
For brands doing $2-10M annually, a boutique agency is usually a better fit than an enterprise shop. You get senior attention without the enterprise rate card.
Netalico, Los Angeles, CA
Founded 2012. 15-30 person team. Focused specifically on Shopify Plus engineering, custom theme development, and performance optimization. One of the more technically-deep boutique Plus partners, they also run productized services like a CRO audit deliverable for mid-market Plus stores. Shopify Plus Partner. Mid-market pricing. Among the best Shopify agencies for DTC brands that need engineering depth without enterprise-agency overhead, this boutique Shopify Plus partner is a regular shortlist entry.
Fuel Made, Seattle, WA
Founded 2010. 15-30 person team. US-based mid-market DTC specialist. Retainer-friendly. Shopify Plus Partner. Mid-market pricing.
Fostr, Denver, CO
Founded 2017. 20-40 person team. Design-forward Shopify Plus. Strong portfolio in US DTC apparel and beauty. Shopify Plus Partner. Mid-market pricing.
Swanky, Brighton, UK
Founded 2011. 50-80 person team. Full-service Plus Elite with strong growth/CRO retainer practice. Shopify Plus Elite. Mid-to-enterprise pricing.
Enterprise-scale Shopify Plus partners
For brands doing $10M+ annually, the bar is different. You need a team that’s shipped dozens of Plus stores, has senior engineering capacity, and has experience with the integrations that matter at scale (ERP, WMS, tax, returns, subscription logic).
Bear Group, Seattle, WA
Founded 2008. 30-50 person team. Long-standing US Plus Partner with strong engineering reputation. Works with DTC apparel, outdoor, and CPG brands. Shopify Plus Partner tier. Mid-to-enterprise pricing.
We Make Websites, London, UK
Founded 2008. 50-100 person team. UK/EU market leader. Long client relationships with brands like Bailey of Hollywood, Bremont, Ganni. Shopify Plus Elite. Enterprise pricing.
Eastside Co, London + US
Founded 2012. 100+ person team. Full-service Plus Elite with offices on three continents. Visible across most “top Shopify agency” listicles. Enterprise pricing.
BVAccel, Los Angeles, CA
Founded 2015. 150+ person team. Largest on this list. Full-service including performance marketing, which can be a pro for brands wanting one vendor or a con for brands wanting specialization. Enterprise pricing.
Design-forward shops
If your hiring criterion is heavily aesthetic, a rebrand is driving the Shopify migration, these two come up consistently.
Underwaterpistol, Glasgow, UK
Founded 2014. 30-60 person team. Design-led Plus builds for brands like Sanctuary Spa, Tangle Teezer, Pip & Nut. Shopify Plus Elite. Mid-to-enterprise pricing.
Barrel, New York, NY
Founded 2006. 50-80 person team. Brand agency with a Shopify practice, works on the positioning and the build together. Clients include SpaceNK, Cadillac, Sakara. Shopify Plus Partner. Enterprise pricing.
Full-service omnichannel
If Shopify is one channel among many and you want a single agency owning paid media, retention, and storefront together.
Tinuiti
Large omnichannel agency with a Shopify practice. Better fit for brands where paid media is already the biggest spend line and the Shopify work sits downstream of it.
How to actually choose
The wrong way is to rank these by team size, DR, or Clutch review count and pick the “best.” The right way is:
Step 1, Define the primary work. Is this a rebrand-driven migration (design-heavy)? A scaling-pain migration (engineering-heavy)? A post-launch optimization retainer (CRO-heavy)? Different agencies are optimized for different work.
Step 2, Shortlist three across the size spectrum. One boutique (Netalico, Fuel Made, Fostr). One mid-size (Swanky, Underwaterpistol, Bear Group). One enterprise (Eastside Co, BVAccel, We Make Websites). This spread gives you honest pricing comparisons and reveals which agency actually fits.
Step 3, Request vertical-matched case studies. A Plus migration for an apparel brand is not the same project as a Plus migration for a CPG subscription brand. Ask for recent work in your vertical, not the agency’s general portfolio.
Step 4, Run a paid discovery phase. Before committing to a full build, pay each shortlisted agency for a 2-4 week scoped discovery. The quality of their discovery deliverable tells you more about what it’s like to work with them than any sales call.
Red flags in agency sales processes
Quick list of things that should pump the brakes:
- Fixed-price proposals for complex Plus migrations without a discovery phase (“we’ll figure it out during the build”)
- Case studies older than 3 years as primary proof (the platform has changed significantly)
- Claim of 50+ clients but refusal to name-drop five specific recent ones
- Reluctance to share team composition (“our senior team will be on it” without naming names)
- All-junior client teams disguised behind an initial senior sales pitch
Final take
No single Shopify agency is objectively best. The best agency for your business is the one whose specialty matches your project shape, whose team composition suits your budget, and whose working style matches yours. For most mid-market DTC brands, a boutique Plus partner is the right call. For enterprise, an Elite-tier shop. For design-driven rebrands, a design-led agency. The surface-level rankings on “best of” listicles will rarely reflect this nuance, do the shortlisting work yourself.
Disclaimer
The information in this article is for general informational purposes only. Agency names, team sizes, pricing tiers, and Shopify partnership statuses mentioned are based on publicly available information as of 2026 and may change. This article does not endorse any specific agency. Readers should conduct their own due diligence, including paid discovery phases and reference checks, before signing any contract.
Begin your learning journey today — find valuable, personalized content designed to help you grow.